課程資訊
課程名稱
文化創意產業專題
Seminar on Cultural Creative Industries 
開課學期
110-1 
授課對象
工學院  建築與城鄉研究所  
授課教師
高郁婷 
課號
BP7121 
課程識別碼
544 M4200 
班次
 
學分
3.0 
全/半年
半年 
必/選修
選修 
上課時間
星期二7,8,9(14:20~17:20) 
上課地點
工綜305 
備註
限碩士班以上
總人數上限:15人
外系人數限制:5人 
Ceiba 課程網頁
http://ceiba.ntu.edu.tw/1101BP7121_CCI 
課程簡介影片
 
核心能力關聯
核心能力與課程規劃關聯圖
課程大綱
為確保您我的權利,請尊重智慧財產權及不得非法影印
課程概述

文化產業、創意產業,或文化創意產業等詞彙自2000年以來風行全球。然而,何謂文創?藝術、傳播、時尚、手工藝、設計、建築、資訊科技,都可以是文創事業;政策與市民行動在無所不包的文化和創意領域,似乎都能找到著力點。文化創意產業成了一個內容曖昧的場域,但其無所不在也意味著,圍繞文化和創意的經濟活動,已然是理解當代社會的關鍵面向。

「文化創意產業專題」不會教人如何創業,也不會深入探索特定產業的商業模式。這門課希望讓大家理解的是文創產業浮現的歷史性社會脈絡,以及能據以檢視並分析文創產業此一現象的批判視角。通過文本閱讀和討論,課堂首先回顧文創過去20年的發展進程,掌握文創產業的國際和本地脈絡。接著,我們會聚焦討論文化經濟(cultural economy)的運作機制,從契約理論、場域的自主性、商品化以及勞動等面向去掌握其運作過程。學期最後,我們也會將討論拉到具體的地方/城市,凸顯文化創意產業的運作總是仰賴並受到實質空間的中介,創意群聚就是明顯例子。然而,城市不只是文創鑲嵌的所在,它也經常期待文創扮演經濟之外的社會性角色。這類理想如何不斷被召喚卻也不斷遇到挫折,將為這門課收尾,有興趣的同學則能循此線索繼續探詢文化與創意之於城市場域的關係。

這門課希望讓同學跳脫狹義的文創產業思考,理解所謂文化與創意的核心價值仍在於人。任何事業或經濟勞動過程因而都有文化與創意的成分存在,如何讓勞動環境能夠支撐人類創造潛能的發揮,因而會是更根本的課題。為此,這門課會要求修課學生以文化創意工作者之於文化經濟的關係為主要命題,撰寫一份期末報告。比如,工作者如何平衡創作與穩定收入、特定的創意勞動如何鑲嵌於特殊的地方或社會關係等。


The term ‘cultural and creative industries’ (CCI) became trendy worldwide at the turn of 21st century. The vagueness of CCI however is as prominent as its popularity. From art, communication, fashion, handicrafts to design, architecture, information technology and so on, CCI is able to occupy some role or another. This haziness easily integrates with both top-down policy initiated by the state and bottom-up civic actions, which then renders CCI an even more ambiguous field.

Given the growing extent of CCI, this course will not be delving into specific industries and will not be teaching students how to launch their own cultural and creative businesses. Rather, the aim will be to familiarize students with the contexts CCI emerge, and to cultivate their ability of analyzing the industries or the so-called cultural and creative economy in question. This orientation of the course is to make sure that students can identity the inner logic of the business or CCI they feel interested, rather than getting carried away by anesthetized discourses.

In the course, we will firstly review the overall development of CCI since the early 2000. As two decades have already passed, critical studies examining the effects and future trajectories of CCI are available. Students can quickly gain a whole picture of CCI at both global and local levels through these readings. Afterwards, we explore how CCI actually works. Cultural economy will be at the core of this set of discussion. Students will be introduced to different aspects inherent to the mechanism of cultural economy. From contract theory and the tensioned balance between creativity vis-à-vis standardization, to the reproduction of symbolic capital, the production and consumption of symbolic commodities, and the often neglected working conditions of cultural workers, students will be gradually gaining analytical views that can be applied to assorted cultural and creative businesses. Before the end of the semester, we will discuss the relations between cultural economy and space. Aside from the fact that cultural industries tend to be embedded within the place, the place—often a city that is—also keeps reminding cultural industries to play more than economic role, but a social one. How this ideal is constantly failed but repetitively evoked will end our discussion of CCI, leaving the students clues to follow if they want to dig further.

Through this course students are expected to think beyond the narrow definition of art and cultural industries, and to recognize the fact that the value of humanity—prominently exemplified as creativity—is inherent in any businesses. What is important is therefore to build industries or working environment that is more wholesome and less alienated. Students will therefore be required to write a paper pivoting on a cultural or creative worker. They will have to record the worker’ s experiences of cultural economy, such as how they tackle risks, balance innovative attempts and stable income, and how they are associated with certain places, clusters or social networks.  

課程目標
1. Having basic understanding about the global and local contexts shaping CCI and causing its emergence.
2. Knowing the major controversies of and criticism on CCI over the two decades.
3. Able to critically analyze the mechanism of cultural and creative economy/businesses through the notions taught in the class.
4. Critically reflecting upon humans’/worker’s role in CCI.
 
課程要求
積極參與課堂討論與導讀任務;對既有的文創現象抱持問題意識;除了要有自己的研究關懷,也應對其它同學的研究題目保持好奇與興趣;期中與期末報告須準時繳交,遲交一天扣5分。
 
預期每週課後學習時數
 
Office Hours
另約時間 
指定閱讀
Week 1 Introduction: why CCI matter?
1. 王俐容(2005)〈文化政策中的經濟論述:從菁英文化到文化經濟?〉。《文化研究》1: 169-195。
2. Florida, Richard 2003. Cities and the Creative Class. City & Community 2(1): 3-19.
3. 王佳煌(2010)〈文化/創意產業、創意階級/城市論著的批判性檢視〉。《思與言》48(1): 131-190。

Week 2 CCI in retrospect: from cultural industry, cultural industries to creative industries
1. Horkheimer, Max. and Theodor Adorno (2008)〈文化工業:作為群眾欺騙的啓蒙〉(林宏濤譯)。《啟蒙的辯證》(pp. 155-210)。臺北:城邦。
2. O’Connor, Justin 2010. The Cultural and Creative Industries: A Review of the Literature (2nd ed.) London: Art Council England.
*Further reading:
1. Adorno, Theodor and Anson G. Rabinbach (1975) Culture Industry Reconsidered. New German Critique (6): 12-19.
2. Kong, L. 2020. From Cultural Industries to Creative Industries and Back? Towards Clarifying Theory and Rethinking Policy. In Handbook on the Geographies of Creativity. Edward Elgar Publishing.

Week 3 CCI in retrospect: institutional change
1. Hesmondhalgh, David (2009)〈緒論:變遷與延續、權力、創意〉,《文化產業分析》(廖珮君譯)(pp. 1-28),台北:韋伯文化。
2. Hesmondhalgh, David (2009)〈文化的研究取徑〉,《文化產業分析》(廖珮君譯)(pp. 29-55),台北:韋伯文化。
3. Hesmondhalgh, David (2009)〈評估文化產業〉,《文化產業分析》(廖珮君譯)(pp. 57-95),台北:韋伯文化。
4. Hesmondhalgh, David (2009)〈解釋文化產業〉,《文化產業分析》(廖珮君譯)(pp. 97-123),台北:韋伯文化。
5. Hesmondhalgh, David (2009)〈政策:法律與規範的變遷〉,《文化產業分析》(廖珮君譯)(pp. 127-160),台北:韋伯文化。
6. Hesmondhalgh, David (2009)〈所有權、組織與文化工作〉,《文化產業分析》(廖珮君譯)(pp. 161-210),台北:韋伯文化。
7. Hesmondhalgh, David (2009)〈國際化、全球化與文化帝國主義〉,《文化產業分析》(廖珮君譯)(pp. 211-241),台北:韋伯文化。
8. Hesmondhalgh, David (2009)〈新媒介、數位化與匯流〉,《文化產業分析》(廖珮君譯)(pp. 243-284),台北:韋伯文化。
9. Hesmondhalgh, David (2009)〈文本:多元性、品質與利益的驅使〉,《文化產業分析》(廖珮君譯)(pp. 285-316),台北:韋伯文化。
10. Hesmondhalgh, David (2009)〈結論:文化產製的新時代嗎?〉,《文化產業分析》(廖珮君譯)(pp. 317-329),台北:韋伯文化。

Week 4 CCI in retrospect: the Asian experiences
1. 王志弘(2012)〈新文化治理體制與國家–社會關係:剝皮寮的襲產化〉。《世新人文社會學報》13: 31-70。
2. 王志弘(2019)〈臺灣都市與區域發展之文化策略批判研究回顧,1990s-2010s〉。《文化研究》29: 13-62。
3. 殷寶寧(2009)〈文化搭台,經濟唱戲?中國文物保護法令與政策變遷歷程分析〉。《台灣國際研究期刊》5(3): 95-119。
4. Iwabuchi K. 2016. Creative Industries and Cool Japan. In: Fung A. (eds) Global Game Industries and Cultural Policy (pp.33-52). Palgrave Global Media Policy and Business. Palgrave Macmillan, Cham. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-40760-9_3
5. Keane M. 2016. Before the Gold Rush: Culture Without Industry in China. In: Fung A. (eds) Global Game Industries and Cultural Policy (pp.53-68). Palgrave Global Media Policy and Business. Palgrave Macmillan, Cham. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-40760-9_4
6. Hye-Kyung Lee 2019. The New Patron State in South Korea: Cultural Policy, Democracy and the Market Economy. International Journal of Cultural Policy 25(1): 48-62.
*Further reading:
1. 王志弘(2003)〈台北市文化治理的性質與轉變,1967-2002〉。《台灣社會研究季刊》52: 121-186。
2. 李世暉(2013)《文化經濟與日本內容產業:日本動畫、漫畫與遊戲的煉金術》。臺北:智勝。
3. 《文化創意產業發展法》(http://www.moc.gov.tw/information_306_19693.html)

Week 5 How cultural economy works
1. Heilbrun, James and Charles M. Gray (2008)《藝術.文化經濟學》(郭書萱、嚴玲娟譯)。台北市:典藏藝術。
2. Abbing, Hans (2008)《為什麼藝術家那麼窮?打破經濟規則的藝術產業》(嚴玲娟譯),台北:典藏。.
*Further readings:
Krueger, Alan (2021) 《搖滾經濟學》(林步昇譯),台北:天下。

Week 6 How cultural economy works (contract theory)
1. Caves, Richard (2003)《文化創意產業:以契約達成藝術與商業的媒合》(上冊)(仲曉玲、徐子超譯),台北市:典藏藝術。
2. Caves, Richard (2003)《文化創意產業:以契約達成藝術與商業的媒合》(下冊)(仲曉玲、徐子超譯),台北市:典藏藝術。
*Further readings:
李令儀(2014)〈文化中介者的中介與介入:出版產業創意生產的內在矛盾〉。《台灣社會學》28: 97 - 147。

Week 7 How cultural economy works(autonomy)
1. 許嘉猷(2004)〈布爾迪厄論西方純美學與藝術場域的自主化-藝術社會學之凝視〉。《歐美研究》34(3): 357-429。
2. Bourdieu, Pierre (2016) 〈序曲〉。《藝術的法則:文學場域的生成與結構》(pp.28-92)(石武耕、李沅洳、陳羚芝譯)。台北市:典藏藝術。
3. 林淇瀁(2009)〈場域.權力與遊戲:從舊書重印論台灣文學出版的經典再塑〉。《東海中文學報》21: 263-86。
4. 林國偉(2013)〈在西方與東方間擺盪-世紀之交臺灣推理文學場域的重構〉。《臺灣文學研究集刊》13: 117-148。
5. Hesmondhalgh, David. 2006. Bourdieu, the Media and Cultural Production. Media, Culture & Society 28(2): 211–231.
*Further reading:
劉碧旭(2020)《觀看的歷史轉型:歐洲藝術展覽的起源與演變》。桃園:時報。

Week 8 How cultural economy works (consumption)
1. Campbell, Colin(2016)《浪漫倫理與現代消費主義精神》(何承恩譯)。臺北:五南。
2. Siriyuvasak, Ubonrat and Shin Hyunjoon (2007) Asianizing K‐pop: Production, Consumption and Identification Patterns among Thai Youth. Inter-Asia Cultural Studies 8:1, 109-136.
3. 李明璁(2015)〈韓國流行音樂的視覺性、身體化與性別展演:以「少女時代」的 MV 產製和消費挪用為例〉《新聞學研究》127: 37-78。
*Further reading:
1. Ullrich, Wolfgang(2015)〈不只是消費:解構產品設計美學與消費社會的心理分析〉(李昕彥譯)。臺北:商周。
2. Shnayerson, Michael (2021)《當代藝術市場瘋狂史》。臺北:時報。

Week 9 *Proposal presentation and submission
Harvey, David (2003)〈地租的藝術:全球化、壟斷與文化的商品化〉(王志弘譯),《城市與設計》第15/16期,pp. 1-19。

Week 10 How cultural economy works (commodification)
Ryan, Bill 1992. Making Capital from Culture (Ch 2,3 &4). New York: Walter de Gruyter.

Week 11 How cultural economy works (commodification)
1. Ryan, Bill 1992. Making Capital from Culture (Ch 5&6). New York: Walter de Gruyter.
2. 鄭瑋寧(2010)〈文化形式的商品化、「心」的工作和經濟治理:以魯凱人的香樁產銷為例〉,《台灣社會學》19: 107-146。
3. 王志弘(2013)〈彈性的藝術–資本矛盾:書封設計的創意勞動與專案團隊〉。《設計學研究》16(2): 95-116。

Week 12 How cultural economy works (labour)
1. Banks, Mark(2015)《文化工作的政治》(王志弘、徐苔玲、沈台訓譯)。新北市:群學。
2. 王志弘(2015)〈藝術工人、服務業專家與美學企業家:室內設計師的生產關係與自我認知〉。《台灣社會研究季刊》101: 125-170。

Week 13 How cultural economy works (labour: risk and gender)
1. 鄭陸霖(2013)〈「陰柔專業性」的可能與弔詭:日本女性室內設計專業的歷史制度形成〉,《社會分析》6: 1-73。*
2. 邱淑宜(2016)〈城市的創意修補及文創工作者的困境-以臺北市為例〉,《都市與計劃》43(1): 1-29。
3. Merkel, J. (2019). ‘Freelance isn’t free’ Co-working as a Critical Urban Practice to Cope with Informality in Creative Labour Markets. Urban Studies 56(3): 526-547.
4. Pajnik, M., & Hrženjak, M. 2020. Engendering Media Work: Institutionalizing the Norms of Entrepreneurial Subjectivity. Journalism, 1464884920922075.
*Further reading:
李明璁、李穎孟(2013)〈從情緒勞動到表演勞動:臺北「女僕喫茶(咖啡館)」之民族誌初探〉。《台灣社會學刊》53: 103-41。

Week 14 Cultural economy in relation to space (clustering)
1. Scott, Allen 2002. A New Map of Hollywood: the Production and Distribution of American Motion Pictures. Regional Studies 36:9: 957-975. (中文版: Scott, Allen J. (2011)〈好萊塢電影創製與發行的地緣新圖像〉,收於李天鐸編著《文化創意產業讀本》(pp. 201-228),台北:遠流。)
2. 殷寶寧(2020)〈審計新村變身記-城市文化治理與創意場域形構〉《博物館學季刊》34(4): 7-32。
3. Zukin, Sharon and Laura Braslow 2011. The Life Cycle of New York’s Creative Districts: Reflections on the Unanticipated Consequences of Unplanned Cultural Zones. City, Culture and Society 2(3): 131-140.
4. 徐瑩峰(2012)〈創意群聚的吸納與排除:台北市中山雙連街區〉《文化研究月報》131: 3-22。

Week 15 Cultural economy in relation to space (civic space lost or regained?)
Zukin, Sharon (1995) The Cultures of Cities. Oxford: Blackwell.

Week 16 Cultural economy in relation to space (civic space lost or regained?)
1. Wang, June, Tim Oakesm and Yang Yang(eds) 2016. Making Cultural Cities in Asia: Mobility, Assemblage, and the Politics of Aspirational Urbanism. London: Routledge.
2. 林文一(2015)〈文化創意導向都市再生、「新」都市治理的實踐及缺憾:以迪化街區為例〉《都市與計劃》42(4): 423-454。
3. 王志弘、高郁婷(2019)〈容不下文化準公地的都市治理?補缺型藝文空間的困局〉。《台灣社會研究季刊》113: 35-74。
*Further reading:
1. Ley, D. 2003. Artists, Aestheticisation and the Field of Gentrification. Urban Studies 40(12): 2527–2544.
2. Lee, S. Y., & Han, Y. 2020. When Art Meets Monsters: Mapping Art Activism and Anti-Gentrification Movements in Seoul. City, Culture and Society 21: 100292.

Week 17 Preparing for final paper

Week 18 *Final paper presentation and submission
 
參考書目
劉俊裕編(2013)《全球都市文化治理與文化策略:藝文節慶、賽事活動與都市文化形象》。高雄:巨流。
殷寶寧(主編)(2021)《藝術管理與文化政策導論》。高雄:巨流。
Oakley, Kate and Justin O'Connor (eds.)(2015) The Routledge Companion to the Cultural Industries. London: Routledge.
 
評量方式
(僅供參考)
 
No.
項目
百分比
說明
1. 
平時成績 (Attendance and participation) 
50% 
修課同學須盡力閱讀課程材料,勇於發問,勤於出席,並分配各周閱讀材料、製作摘要。本課程採取講演和討論課(seminar)並行方式,每次上課由教師講授和提示重點,並由分配到該週閱讀材料的同學導讀,每篇報告時間須控制於十五分鐘,盡量留時間發問和討論。報告者須分發書面提要(必須包含三百字以內之摘述,主要論點和論證邏輯之說明【配合論證圖示】,以及評論和問題)。 沒有分配到當週閱讀材料導讀的同學,則需繳交針對某一篇或全部閱讀材料的讀書心得和提問,至少一頁。旁聽的同學,不需分配閱讀材料的導讀,也不必繳交作業,但是必須每堂課繳交讀書心得和提問。 期中與期末之計劃書和期末報告課堂呈現,修課同學也應積極參與,給予同儕建議並相互討論。  
2. 
期末報告計劃書 (Proposal presentation and submission) 
20% 
期中時同學須繳交一份三頁以內計劃書,說明期末研究主題的問題意識、相關文獻和研究方法,並須於課堂上以簡報方式向教師與同學呈現內容,發表時間須控制在十五分鐘以內。 
3. 
期末報告 (Final paper presentation and submission) 
30% 
期末同學須繳交一份約一萬五千字的報告,並在課堂上以簡報分享,時間須控制在十五分鐘內。書面報告格式可參照《臺灣社會學刊》,須包含中英文題目、中文摘要及關鍵詞等項目。 
 
課程進度
週次
日期
單元主題
第2週
9/28  Introduction: why CCI matter? 
第3週
10/05  CCI in retrospect: from cultural industry to creative industries 
第4週
10/12  CCI in retrospect: institutional change 
第5週
10/19  CCI in retrospect: the Asian experiences 
第6週
10/26  How cultural economy works  
第7週
11/02  How cultural economy works (contract theory) 
第8週
11/09  How cultural economy works(autonomy) 
第9週
11/16  How cultural economy works (consumption) 
第10週
11/23  *Proposal presentation and submission 
第11週
11/30  How cultural economy works (commodification) 
第12週
12/07  How cultural economy works (commodification) 
第13週
12/14  How cultural economy works (labour) 
第14週
12/21  How cultural economy works (labour: risk and gender) 
第15週
12/28  Cultural economy in relation to space (clustering) 
第16週
1/04  Cultural economy in relation to space (civic space lost or regained?) 
第17週
1/11  Cultural economy in relation to space (civic space lost or regained?) 
第18週
1/18  1/18 *Final paper presentation and submission